Fat Boys is awful. They first opened in Phelps on Main Street and my kids could not stand it when their father would order from there. Well, they came to Geneva and took over the old Nicky's, talk about good pizza, Nicky's had amazing pizza and wings. The pizza dough was homemade, you could definitely tell and their prices were not bad either. It was sad to see Nicky's go, we didn't even know he was closing up shop, went in one day the next week and Fat Boys had taken over. It was the worst pizza and wings I have ever tried. Never went back and won't go back. I don't know how they stay in business. The Geneva location never looks busy at all and neither does the Phelps location. Anybody I know that has ever tried it, says it is awful!!!
Those people who think they know everything are a great annoyance to those of us who do.